Monday, August 06, 2012

Scone or scone? That is the question


One thing led to another, and I found myself trapped on page 326 of "Pies and Prejudice", Stuart Maconie's epic exploration of the North of England. The trouble being - having read the entire book with Mr Maconie's voice in my head, I had come up against a single word, without a clue as to how he might pronounce it.

The word was "scone".

Do you - I asked him through the medium of Twitter - say "scone" to rhyme with "stone" or "gone"? He does not reply, but it is too late, I need to know, for it is a question that has haunted me for my entire life. I dare say it has defined me somewhat. Defined me as a bit of a twat.

Having been brought up in the 1970s, one of my finest memories is the Bunfight at the OK Tearooms epsidoe of The Goodies, where the trio fall out over this very question, with near fatal results.

So, I asked my followers on the Twitter and the Facebook. How do you say it, and where do you live?

The result is this map in wonderful Comic Sans-o-Vision, the Font of Champions

As you can see, there is a fair spread of skon / skown, with a couple of contrary jokers north of the border insisting on "skoon". However, it is clear that "skon" (which many may think is the working class option) heavily outnumbers the more plummy "skown", but I imagine that it's skon people who end up suffering as the skowner sit around having cream teas at the Savoy.

But - most tellingly - it's "skown" in Southampton and "skon" in Portsmouth, and a similar divide between Dublin and Belfast; while there's a battle between the two in the viarious suburbs of Manchester, spreading hate and despiar right across Lancashire. No wonder the world's completely fucked up.

It's "skon", by the way. The rest of you can just SHUT UP.

9 comments:

Richard said...

Stuart Maconie is not to be trusted. The description of Crewe library in that book is of an entirely different building and as it's virtually at the start it casts a huge doubt on the veracity of the rest of it. I think he made it all up.

TRT said...

If you have one with cream and jam, though, does the cream go below the jam or above?

Ceiliog said...

I asked the maid in dulcet tone
To order me a buttered scone.
The silly girl has been and gone
And ordered me a buttered scone.
Anon - Curious and Comic Verse. pub: Penguin.

Anonymous said...

Jaam Bootée

as the French call it.

Anonymous said...

Or in the US

Biskit!

Marianne said...

I'm hungry now.

Sewmouse said...

I before E except after C, or when sounded like "a" as in neighbour and weigh.

When 2 vowels go walking the first one does the talking..

The silent "E" at the end of a word makes the vowel in the middle say its own name.

Therefore: Sk(oh)n

TRT said...

Oh, so that's how it works. I Really must phon you sometime.

Cougar said...

It has to be 'skon', otherwise the "what's the fastest cake in the world" joke doesn't work. Which, after all, is the important thing.